27 May 2012
Dear Phyllis,
These past two weeks have been very interesting in a highly unpleasant, negative, way. I could do with a lot less problems like we are faced with at the moment.
It has been nearly a month since we got our daughter, Annie. She is adorable! We love her very much. But shortly after we brought her home. Pammy began to notice that something was out of line. She had a very foul odor from her crouch. And when Pammy bathed her, she complained about pain in her vaginal area. We had been home about a week or so when one night Pammy came to me in a near panic. She said, Annie told her about getting molested (raped). We were horrified! But her story was very consistent. She said that the man in charge of the children's home, where we got her, was the offender. IMPOSSIBLE! But she told us in detail how he had repeatedly molested her and two other young girls living there.
I called Pastor Kichikun the next day and relayed the story to him. ABSOLUTELY IMPOSSIBLE!!!Pastor Kichikun had been close friends with him for over 20 yeas and vowed there was no way a man of that impeccable character could do such a heinous thing. But, of course, Annie would have to have a medical examination.
We were able to take her to an excellent lady pediatrician, who is also an outstanding Christian sister. Dr. Suprea was horrified when we sat in her office and explained the purpose for our visit. She said, “If this is true, this is a very BIG STORY.” Ten minutes later she turned to me and grimly confirmed, there is no question but what she has been violated. Dr. Suprea could not be specific what had done the damage, but there was no question but what someone had molested her. The hymen was destroyed, and obvious evidence of disruption in her vagina. She had vaginal infection which was causing the bad odor. Dr. Suprea gave us some medication to clear up the infection and instructed us to go immediately to a hospital for further clinical examination.
But that was a big problem. If we took Annie to a hospital, that would kick over an enormous bees nest. If a child is brought into the hospital that is clinically confirmed to have been molested, it is a criminal offense if the hospital does not notify the police immediately. This was one course of action we did not want to take at this point.
Unfortunately, the Thai police are not distinguished as being the most competent, honest, police force in the world. Just as certain as it rains in Thailand in the summer, it is common knowledge that there is lamentable corruption with Thai police. Two years ago, a tragic incident had happened here in Chiang Mai. The Mennonites had an outstanding nanny ministry where godly Mennonite girls were coming from the states to take care of unwanted babies until they could be transferred for adoption a year or two later. An utterly unimaginable scenario happened to two babies that looked like a criminal act. The police came to an instant mistaken conclusion, and the man who was in charge of that ministry had to flee the country to avoid prosecution. Shelton is one of the most godly men I have ever met. They had been very very careful about the quality of girl they permitted to engage in this ministry. He swore it was impossible for any of these girls to do what it appeared had happened. It was a medical problem – not a criminal act. I am sure the Mennonites were innocent, but that was not considered in the police report. I didn't want a repeat of that with the children's home.
Now, very clearly, a serious crime had taken place in molesting a three year old girl. This is a crime next to murder – if not worse. Two things must be done. First of all, whoever did it, must be stopped. There must be an absolute guarantee that this would never happen again. Secondly, the Thai law demands that there must be a penalty for such a crime. It is not Christian to try to negate the Thai law to protect the guilty person. He must be prosecuted, and pay for his deeds.
But there are two ways of dealing with this. One is to turn it over to the police. The second is to try to clean up the mess ourselves, and then have the perpetrator turn himself into the police. I saw serious potential damage done if we just called the police. An innocent man might get convicted, and the collateral damage could be severe. If it was proven – or even highly suspected – that the problem was the children's home, that would almost certainly mean the the children's home would be closed. Next, the Thai social service workers would step in, take all the children, and send them to government homes. We saw a real possibility of having even Annie taken away from us and put in a government home. We certainly didn't want that.
Annie was very consistent in her story that the director of the children's home was the offender. But then a second man was involved. It seemed that two men had molested her. Both were very godly men.
To me this was a church problem. When we had confirmed, by the medical examination, that a rape had taken place, I called Kichikun again, and told him that he must contact the president of his organization, and they must handle it. Then things began to go sideways.
Kichikun called the head of the children's home and asked him if he had done it. Of course not. He was shocked. Kichikun and I began to line up on different pages. We were agreed on the final resolution, but how to get there was the question. On Saturday our discussion began to polarize so badly that I finally said, “Alright. I'm out. Do it the way that you feel is best.”
Pastor Kichikun called Pastor Sahat in Bangkok, who is the president of their organization, setting up a meeting in Bangkok on Monday. I had met Pastor Sahat at the Baptist camp meeting last month and have only the highest respect for him. Sunday night the four of us – Pammy, Annie, and I, and Kichikun – took a night bus down to Bangkok. I had told Kichikun that I was out, and refused to attend the meeting. Four hours later Kichikun came back to the room where I had been waiting very pleased with the outcome of the meeting. Annie had changed her story again, and it turned out that the whole thing was an accident when she got struck by a stick by her 5 year old twin brothers (boys staying at the home).
Much later, when we arrived back home in Chiang Mai, I asked Pammy if she was satisfied with the final decision at the meeting. No. There were a lot of things that had been poorly handled. Annie again reverted to her original story and nothing had been actually proven true.
A few days later we spent a very profitable hour taking with Dr. Suprea. She was utterly astounded when she heard that Annie had been confronted by the man she was accusing of raping her before her testimony could be heard by the committee in the room. I asked her, “Is it possible that the damage done to her vagina, and the subsequent vaginal infection, could be cause by a stick?” Absolutely impossible! Now what do we do? Dr. Suprea agreed with me that there was little to gain by calling the police. They could go to the children's home but there was no evidence to substantiate anything. All we had was the vacillating story of a three year old girl. I asked about a child psychologist, but Dr. Suprea thought there was little to gain from that.
Now Annie has changed her story for the fourth time. She says that a different man had picked her up to take her to see her generic father, and he had done it. This is the most plausible explanation yet. She has given up accusing the director of the children's home. I would like to believe that he is innocent, and Kichikun is totally convinced that it is impossible for either he, or the other godly brother, to do such a vile thing.
This may never be settled this side the Judgment Throne of Christ. What we have been dealing with is like trying to use a weather vein for a magnetic compass. Annie has a known weakness in handling truth. Unsurprisingly, she has demonstrated that she too is a sinner. Like all children she has lied to us about other things. Dealing with such a traumatic experience, she has vacillate in her mind what actually happened. One thing we do know is that justice will be done. But perhaps not in this life.
It is tragic that such a serious accusation was leveled against a very godly man. But nothing can be proved. It can't be proven that I didn't do it. But Pammy will testify that I am innocent. (Annie says that Daddy is a good man.)
This has been a very uncomfortable three weeks. There is little question but what Annie has been violated by someone. We have been very confidential about this matter with other people. It would be unfortunate if this story was widely circulated. Two brothers that we did share our dilemma with were critical that we didn't notify the police immediately. In retrospect, I still fear there could have been serious collateral damage done, needlessly, if, less than infallible, police had handled the case.
Physically she has recovered nicely. When we first got her, her vagina looked enormous. This has shrunk up to normal size. The infection has cleared up. She has an unsurprising hostility towards men. Every morning she is hostile against me. But as the day wears on, she doesn't want Daddy to set her down. We spend a lot of time playing every day. She has made the adjustment of living here. She has totally bonded to Mommy and Daddy. It is gratifying so see a happy little girl smiling and laughing much of every day. Jesus is doing His work in all of our hearts. Our prayer is, that as she gets older, this will completely fade from her mind. We have our work cut out for us in raising this precious gift to be a flower for Jesus in God's beautiful garden.
This may sound like a dramatic story, but, tragically, we are only the tip of an iceberg. As bad as this story is, it pales in comparison to untold millions of other child abuse incidents that go on continually. Recently, I read a Dave Wilkerson book of testimonies of his work with street young people in New York. They are nauseating. And yet it is from these sordid messes that the Lord is calling out His Bride. God has reached into the garbage can of humanity to call out a holy people for His Son. If we were commissioned of God to go out to find the most lovely, spotless virgin to be presented to His Son as His eternal companion, where would we look? That would be a tough assignment. John had a similar dilemma when confronted with the question, “Who is WORTH to open the Book and loose the Seals?”(Rev. 5:2). That problem was simply to find someone worth to open the book. This would be much more difficult to find someone worth to be His Bride. John wept because there was no one found worth in heaven or earth worth to do that. But God has reached to the bottom of the slop bucket to find the ones for Jesus. And in Rev. 21 we see the Bride of Christ is the most beautiful being God ever created. She is the finest gift the Father could present to His Son. The cleansing Blood of Jesus is wonderful. She is truly beautiful.
Praise God, Annie has been saved from a life of abuse. Hopefully, she will be a lovely rose for Jesus. But there are countless thousands of others in far worse condition that are waiting to be reached.
His letter is somewhat confidential, but we need your prayers,
bill